Organic Dairy Cow Health

Home

Organic Dairy
Business Directory

Marketplace
-free classifieds

Calendar of Events
-in the Northeast

Industry News

Organic dairy
-certifying agencies
-resources
-transitioning
-cow health
-grazing management and soil health

Organic Standards,
Political Action &
Alerts

Become a
NODPA member

Join the Organic Dairy
(O-DAIRY)
email discussion list

NODPA mission statement

NODPA hats, stickers

NODPA history

NODPA representatives

NODPA newsletters

Disclaimer: NODPA does not endorse companies or businesses, but wants to provide education and resource information for organic dairy producers. We urge organic producers to check with their certifier before trying a new product or practice.

  • Some Thoughts on Holistic or Alternative Veterinary Medicine by Richard J. Holliday, DVM
    Part 1
    Part 2

Some Thoughts on Holistic or Alternative Veterinary Medicine

Part 1

By Richard J. Holliday, DVM

It is a difficult task to briefly describe "holistic" or "alternative" veterinary medicine. The dictionary defines "holistic" as being concerned with wholes or with complete systems rather than with parts or divisions, while "alternative" describes something existing or functioning outside the established cultural, social, or economic system. Both definitions are correct but do not adequately address the wide variations within the realm of holistic veterinary medicine as practiced today.

The range of alternative therapies is immense...acupuncture, herbs, homeopathy, refined colostrum products, microbial products (lactobacilli and yeasts), mega-vitamins, radionics, and many other natural products and procedures. The list goes on and on and I apologize if I've left out someone's favorite therapy. Most are useful and generally effective alternatives to the drugs, hormones and antibiotics commonly used in veterinary medicine today.

A HOLISTIC PRACTITIONER
I believe that the distinguishing characteristic of holistic practitioners is the way they approach problems...in short, the way they think. A true holistic practitioner not only looks at the patient as an integrated unit but also views it in the context of the whole ecosystem in which it lives. In this regard, a sick animal is not only a patient to be treated but is also a symptom of a sick farm. Both patients need help. Any remedial action must include what is necessary for the immediate relief of the patient as well as a critical assessment of the long-term effects of the chosen therapy on the patient and the environment. Part of the treatment must also be the removal or reduction of predisposing factors.

A holistic practitioner should also be well versed in several treatment modalities and be able to pick the most appropriate ones needed in any situation.

Finally, a true holistic practitioner should emphasize holistic animal health management (proactive) rather than any kind of treatment (reactive), whether it be holistic or conventional.

It should be noted that the terms holistic and alternative are not interchangeable. For example: an acupuncturist may be practicing alternative medicine, but if he only treats symptoms and does not search for the cause or other useful therapies he is probably not a holistic practitioner … a fine distinction perhaps, but a significant one.

ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES
To me, the greatest advantage to the holistic approach is that it works! In the hands of an experienced practitioner most holistic/alternative treatments have as good or a better success rate than conventional therapy. I think this is true because holistic practitioners attempt to find and treat the cause not just the symptoms.

There are many other advantages to holistic medicine ... less pollution, fewer side effects, and especially the fact that holistic medicine follows the old medical axiom, “at least do no harm.” This advice seems to have been lost or overlooked in the U.S. as evidenced by the recent report that pharmaceutical drugs are now either the 4th or 6th leading cause of death.

Unfortunately, several factors have slowed public acceptance. The sale and use of natural products do not generate the huge profits necessary to buy researchers, lobbyists, and politicians as does the sale of antibiotics, pharmaceuticals, herbicides and insecticides. Thus we have little credibility in some circles because we do not have research to back up our empirical observations.

Because so few schools teach these advanced concepts, there are not enough qualified practitioners, although the number is growing. Those that do engage in holistic practice are often subjected to harassment by government agencies.

The biggest disadvantage is that most people tend to use it for the wrong reasons and at the wrong time! They will turn to alternative treatments only as a last resort when everything conventional medicine has to offer has failed. Usually by this time the patient is in advanced stages of the disease and also suffering from the side effect of all the prescribed drugs they have used. When the alternative approach also fails, and it usually does in this situation, the patient gives up on the entire concept and never realizes that the alternative treatment might have worked had they used the right product or technique at the right time. Unfortunately, this apparent “failure” provides more evidence for the pharmaceutical /medical complex to ridicule and condemn the entire concept of holistic medicine.

THE FOCUS OF HOLISTIC ANIMAL HUSBANDRY
The success of the holistic approach requires a change in perspective and the development of a holistic outlook towards livestock management and disease control. It is not as simple as merely substituting a “natural” alternate therapy for a “toxic” drug. The principles behind the success of holistic therapy go much deeper than the characteristics or source of the medication.

Conventional Veterinary Medicine is primarily concerned with the treatment of sick animals. Even if successful, the loss of life and production added to the cost of treatment makes this approach by far the most expensive.

Veterinarians also emphasize disease prevention. Herd health checks and vaccination programs fall into this category. As essential as these procedures are, the outlook is still towards preventing disease. Vaccinations may increase resistance against a specific organism but lowers the animal’s general vitality to other challenges. Typical of this category are herds or flocks where the animals are not really sick or showing symptoms but are not really well and productive either.

A third concept, usually neglected by conventional veterinary practitioners, is that of health enhancement through holistic management. Everything possible is done to raise health and vitality to the highest level possible. All management practices are evaluated on the basis of their effects on the vitality of each animal in the herd. Strict attention is given to providing superlative nutrition. In so far as possible, all environmental stress factors are eliminated. Water is checked for nitrates or other toxins. Housing and ventilation are maintained at optimum levels. Any equipment with which the animals come in contact is properly maintained and adjusted. There are literally hundreds of other environmental factors that impact animal health and they all must be considered. When animals are maintained at a high level of vitality their resistance is much higher. Health enhancement is much more profitable than either treatment or prevention.

Please feel free to contact me with any questions, comments or criticisms at rjhdvm@rconnect.com or rjhdvm@aol.com.

Dr. Richard Holliday has worked for IMPRO for the past 18 years as the Technical Services Veterinarian. Prior to that, he had a private mixed practice in northwest Missouri for 25 years. He became certified as a Veterinary Acupuncturist in 1988 and has been actively promoting organic agriculture and holistic veterinary medicine for over 30 years.

Dr. Holliday will be in ME, VT, and NY in January 2004 for healthcare workshops. See calendar for details.


Some Thoughts on Holistic or Alternative Veterinary Medicine

Part 2

SOME THOUGHTS ABOUT STRESS

• Stress is known to lower immune function and may be the primary factor that sets the stage for animal disease.

• There are three categories of stress.

1. Environmental or physical stress, such as faulty nutrition, bad water, lack of sanitation, poorly designed and maintained equipment, unsuitable habitat, etc. Good management has some influence on most of these but can not control all of them. For example, weather cannot be controlled but the effects can be mitigated with proper housing.

2. Physiological stress usually associated with reproduction and lactation. We can minimize some of the effects of this type, but we can not totally eliminate it.

3. Psychological stress may occurs when weaning, changing groups, establishing a new “pecking order”, etc.. This type can be held to an acceptable level with good management.

• All animals vary in their ability to accommodate stress. Some differences are due to inheritance ... species, breed and sex. Others are associated with the individual’s life history of health and disease. Older animals do not accommodate stress as well as younger ones do. A kid that suffers an episode of severe scours/pneumonia may survive, grow and appear thrifty even though some irreversible damage to heart, lungs and intestinal lining may forever impair it’s ability to pump blood and absorb oxygen and nutrients. Under stress this animal will probably show earlier and more severe symptoms than others in the same group that did not go through the sickness

• Stresses are cumulative. A small stress has a greater effect in an animal already carrying a big stress load, than it has in another relatively stress free animal .

THE VITALITY CHART

Over many years, I have developed a graph or map that allows me focus my thinking and helps me keep the various aspects of health and disease in their proper perspective. Any animal’s relative health status can be plotted on this graph. Since this Vitality Chart also seems useful to illustrate certain principles of holistic thought. I would like to share it with you and will use it as the basis for this article and for almost all future discussions of health and disease.

On the chart, note that the “vitality” line on the left side (looks like a thermometer) runs from PERFECT HEALTH to DEAD. I purposefully do not assign any numbers because the positions are variable and I’d rather think in terms of relationships and not absolutes. I doubt we ever attain perfect health but “DEAD” is common.

The “profitability line” indicates a relative loss of production, profitability or performance. The “clinical line” by definition separates healthy animals from sick animals. Based solely on the presence or absence of symptoms. These lines are actually wide, gray areas and their position arbitrary and quite variable. It depends a great deal on how well the herdsman relates to and observes his animals.

Physiological and psychological stresses are represented on the chart as a wavy gray line. These stresses usually occur at predetermined times, such as parturition, weaning, and other routine changes or events.

If an animal progressively declines from good health to sickness or even death (going straight down the left side of the chart), it will first cross the ‘profitability line” as it becomes less productive and then the “clinical line” when it begins to show symptoms of disease. These symptoms may be mild at first, ... “a little off,” ... gradually increasing in severity until “DEAD”. (See Vitality Chart) We know and accept that there are differing levels of illness but our management decisions frequently seem to be based on the premise that animal “B” is just as healthy as animal “A”. We all know that different levels of health do exist but in practice we tend to overlook this because “A” and “B” both look equally healthy even though there is great difference in their respective vitality. Production records and breeding records are a great aid to identify those animals that have lost productivity but are not yet showing symptoms.

Let’s compare the reactions of “Spot” and “Star”, both living a relatively stress free life and having a high level of vitality. (position 1 on the chart) If something happens to their ration and they are subjected to nutritional stress, they will probably both decline in vitality to position 2. Notice that Spot was affected more severely, possibly because she suffered a grave illness when young (as discussed earlier). Both still appear to be healthy and productive but some of their “reserve” is used up.

Adding another stress causes both to slip down to position 3. Star is still doing well but now Spot has dropped under the profitability line. She shows no clinical symptoms but performance or production testing may indicate problems. In a dairy animal this could be evidenced by lowered production, a change in SCC or an impairment of breeding efficiency.

Add one more stress and Spot and Star fall to position 4, both below the profitability line. Spot is dangerously close to the clinical line but still shows no obvious symptoms although a really close observer might see mild symptoms developing.

As one last insult, let’s expose them both to pathogenic bacteria capable of causing disease. Both suffer the same loss of vitality from this exposure (striped line). Star dips in vitality but does not go “clinical”. She is able to overcome the infection because she had some resistance left. Spot drops over the line and begins to show symptoms. Conventional medicine would diagnose the bacteria as the “cause” of her disease.

This example is obviously oversimplified to illustrate a principle, but does beg the question: “In this example, did the germs cause the disease? Or would it be more accurate to ask: “Did the bacteria trigger a disease in an animal that was already suffering from stress-induced, low vitality?” I go with the trigger theory. The deciding factor was not the presence or absence of a disease organism, but the presence of induced, low vitality?” I go with the trigger theory. The deciding factor was not the presence or absence of a disease organism, but the presence of absence of a strong immune system. Obviously, microorganisms do vary in their ability to cause disease and a highly pathogenic organism may be able to cause disease in relatively stress free animals. These epidemics however are probably not as costly in the long run as the day-to-day losses incurred by common infections.

I think we give germs way too much weight as the cause of problems. My guess is that a germ can’t tell if an animal is dead or alive ... but if an animal is so “stressed out” that it “tastes” dead to the bacteria, they immediately begin the recycling process. In a dead animal we call it decomposition ... in a live animal we call it disease. In the grand scheme of things, the “bugs “ are probably only doing the job assigned to them.

SOME OBSERVATIONS BASED ON THE CHART

• Let’s go back to poor old Spot’s predicament. We could give her some antibiotics and hopefully kill enough germs to get her back up over the clinical line. Or, we could treat her with herbs, or homeopathy or whatever and probably help her enough to shut off the symptoms. BUT, unless we eliminate the stresses that put her at the susceptible level in the first place, we have really only installed a big Band-Aid!

• Timing is critically important. If you start treatment early, a mild treatment has a greater chance of getting results. If this is not successful, you still have time to escalate to a more heroic treatment. Some conventional dairymen overlook the importance of timing when their hope for a spontaneous recovery leads them to withhold treatment of sick animals until the last possible moment in order to minimize the economic loss of discarded milk or meat. A holistic treatment does not have this disadvantage and can be used anytime.

• Generally speaking, the closer to the top of the chart we recognize a problem and begin to correct it, the lower the cost.

• If healing and/or health occurs at all, it is a function of the natural inclination of the animal to be healthy. Drugs, from whatever source derived, only aid this natural process.

• Just because an animal shows no symptoms does not mean it’s healthy.

• The final stress that triggers symptoms is usually not the primary cause of the illness. For example, bacteria may “trigger” mastitis but the real “cause” may be nutritional deficiencies or other stresses.

A QUIZ!

If you are already following holistic principles or aspire to do so, you should be able to answer these questions. If you can’t answer them, you have some homework to do.

1. Is the ration adequate with no excesses, deficiencies or toxins? Were the feeds grown on fertile soil with little or no chemical contamination? Are the feed ingredients appropriate to the species, type and age of the animals?

2. Is the water pure? Has it been checked for nitrates and other harmful chemicals? What is the actual nitrate level in the water? Do you drink from the same water supply as the animals? Does the water taste good to you?

3. Are there any harmful electrical or electromagnetic influences on the premise? Do you ever receive mild electrical shocks when working in the area where the animals are kept?

4. If used, is milking equipment properly maintained and adjusted?

5. Are all procedures involving the animals such as milking, vaccinating, and routine surgery carried out in a timely and sanitary manner?

6. Do your animals have a clean, dry, well-ventilated environment when confined? Can you kneel down in the pens without getting wet knees? Is breathing uncomfortable or unpleasant to you when breathing at the same distance above the ground as the animal breathes in air?

7. Is there any evidence of mold, mycotoxins or aflatoxins in the feed? Some are not apparent until symptoms occur, ... have you checked?

Please feel free to contact me with any questions, comments or criticisms at rjhdvm@rconnect.com
or rjhdvm@aol.com

Dr. Richard Holliday has worked for IMPRO for the past 18 years as the Technical Services Veterinarian. Prior to that, he had a private mixed practice in northwest Missouri for 25 years. He became certified as a Veterinary Acupuncturist in 1988 and has been actively promoting organic agriculture and holistic veterinary medicine for over 30 years.


(W)HOLISTIC ANIMAL HUSBANDRY

by Jerry Brunetti

Practitioners using alternative approaches to livestock health have to ultimately concern themselves with several fundamental keynotes that are inextricably associated with livestock performance and health, regardless of whether the therapeutic modalities used are allopathic or naturopathic. To truly address the fundamental issues discussed herein, thorough attention must be given to the physical, chemical and biological needs of soils.

THE FIVE DIGESTIVE KEYNOTES

1) Maintain proper acid/alkaline balance. The flora/fauna in the gut are very pH dependent. (Ideal rumen pH - 6.4) Additionally the pH of the cell and blood stream are maintained at a very narrow window of tolerance. Check fecal pH to determine pH levels. For ruminants, increase fiber (ADF) and/or reduce grain to enhance salivation which will increase rumen pH. For ruminants and monogastrics, cationic minerals such as calcite, dolomite, magnesium oxide, sodium bicarbonate, montmorillionite will increase alkalinity; reduce acidity. Free choice and observe/record levels of consumption.

2) The “internal eco-system”, that is the G.I. Tract, is becoming deprived of necessary innoculants livestock obtain from the leaf surfaces of forages and the soil as well. This can be especially critical for monogastrics like swine and poultry, but very important to ruminants also. These organisms produce enzymes, growth inhibitors for pathogens, B-vitamins and many unidentified nutrient factors (UNF’s) necessary for metabolic and immune function. In lieu of grazing, conventionally produced livestock have been supplemented with antibiotics to help suppress pathogen levels. But, drug resistance has created dangerous strains of E Coli, salmonella, camphylobacter, etc. That are now more frequently appearing in the food supply. Additionally, these drugs are immuno-suppressive and interfere with friendly indigenous strains. “Alternative” products can be “probiotics” and enzymes, that can either be purchased from commercial outlets or perhaps obtained from the farm’s own topsoil or compost. Herbal bitters, some of which have been reported to be fed since colonial times in America and herbal G.I. Tract stimulants may also be a renewed arcane resource (e.g. Ginger, cayenne pepper, gentian root, peppermint.)

3) Blood Urea Nitrogen (B.U.N.) also tested as Milk Urea Nitrogen (M.U.N.) suggests that either too much protein or typically too much “funny protein” which is non-protein nitrogen (NPN) is being consumed. Crude protein merely measures nitrogen, not amino acids, which are needed to repair tissue, build hormones, enzymes, immune cells, detoxify lymph, etc. B.U.N. Suppresses the immune system, feeds pathogens, reduces oxygenation of the cells, overworks liver and kidney, and reduces conception. Make sure forages are grown on mineral-rich and mineral-balanced soils including adequate secondary & trace nutrients. Rapidly available energy such as found in molasses, finely ground grain and digestible cellulose (e.g.beet pulp) will assist in balancing the energy: protein ratio in the rumen. Specific “edible” mineral-rich clays to absorb excess NH3 will also help.

4) Molds and Mycotoxins can present a very serious herd/flock crisis and need to be dealt without hesitation. Molds & Mycotoxins are very toxic, damaging the liver, G.I. tract, kidneys, lungs, etc. Ultimately, poor agronomic practices and toxic chemical remedies must be addressed; sustainable soil practices are a must. Utilizing absorbents such a zeolite, montmorillionite, bentonite, activated carbon will help neutralize some of the metabolic toxins; few options are available to control the mold organism growth; propionic acid, iodine, etc. can be of some assistance. Animals affected should be given additional levels of vitamins (25% higher) and probiotics/enzymes to assist with compromised digestion and poor appetite.

5) Mineral imbalances and mineral deficiencies: Ca:K, Ca:P, K:Na, N:S, are very important to metabolic performance in animals. Trace minerals like cobalt, copper, boron, selenium, zinc, etc. are not necessarily found in many soils at adequate levels today and are vitally important for peak growth, performance, immunity, reproduction, sound feet, longevity and so forth. Free choice mineral supplements, if done correctly, can be a very inexpensive input to correct imbalances and deficiency. Naturally occurring “rare earth” minerals and kelp meal can also be part of the “missing link” laundry list to provide hard to get micro-nutrients.

Important! Keep accurate records over sustained periods of time to determine what is being consumed. This may correlate them to the above-mentioned issues of pH, NPN, molds, etc. as well as excesses of deficiencies of minerals.

For specific ailments the use of nutraceuticals (oral and injectable vitamins/minerals), probiotics (micro-flora and enzymes), essential oils, herbs (given raw, dried or water extract) can be especially effective on all animals raised both conventionally and organically. Calf scours, mastitis, ketosis, milk fever, “off-feed” can all be addressed effectively economically and ecologically utilizing the aforementioned raw materials, especially if the stockman is paying attention to the preventative key notes itemized as 1-5.

Always consult with homeopathic veterinarian for specific homeopathic remedies for the following!

SPECIFIC TREATMENTS

1) Mastitis and Somatic Cell

a) Check trace mineral levels of Zinc, iodine, selenium, copper
b) Colostrum Whey
c) Anti-oxidant vitamins (C,E, A) {both injectable & feed-grade}
d) Mash/gruel of vinegar, molasses, bran, beet pulp
e) Herbal Extracts - cayenne, ginger, mint, licorice, Echinacea, garlic
f) Massage Udder - with “hot” linament (camphor, peppermint, capsicum, etc)

2) Ketosis
a) I.V. Glucose
b) Drench with liquid energy sources containing propylene glycol, sugar(s), grain alcohol, acetic/lactic acid
c) B-vitamins, especially niacin (12 grams/day)
d) Crude liver extract
e) Probiotics to help appetite
f) Herbal extracts to help digestion (ginger, fenugreek, cayenne, licorice, peppermint & fennel) Herbs for liver health (dandelion leaf, burdock root, yellow dock root, milk thistle seed)

3) Milk Fever
a) I.V. Calcium/Dextrose (also use Vitamin C to assist calcium transport)
b) Calcium Drench with Calcium (lactate, acetate, propionate, oxide); Magnesium (oxide sulfate); Vitamin D;Phosphorous (Calcium phosphate);zinc (sulfate, chelate);cobalt (sulfate chelate); B-12

4) Udder Edema
a) Inject Vitamins: B-6, B-12
b) Diuretic Herbs: dandelion leaf/root, celery seed, juniper berries, gravel root, cleavers
c) Massage udder with “hot” linament (camphor, peppermint, capsicum, etc)
d) 1 pint of strong coffee

5) Calf Scours
a) Use demulcent herbs like psyllium, comfrey, slippery elm, mallow; astringent herbs like raspberry leaf, blackberry root bayberry; anti-microbial herbs like oregon grape, bearberry, peppermint, eucalyptus, garlic, thyme
b) Activated carbon, clays (montmorillonite, bentonite, attapulgatite, etc.)
c) Electrolytes with buffers
d) Probiotics/enzymes
e) Colostrum whey

6) Foot Rot
a) Correct acidosis with minerals/fiber
b) Increase iodine, zinc and sulfur
c) Topical foot bathe with copper and zinc sulfate, and iodine
d) Good pasture - grass factors & nutritional/medicinal herbs

7) Reproduction Problems
a) Correct acid/alkaline balance
b) Address M.U.N./B.U.N.
c) Adequate A, E, copper, cobalt, zinc, iodine, B-complex, selenium, iron(?)
d) “Grass Factors” - enzymes, carotenoids, Vitamin E, trace minerals, nutritional & medicinal herbs

8) Respiratory Problems
a) Inject A, E, C, B-complex vitamins
b) Hydrogen Peroxide (Food Grade) drench
c) Inject Colostrum Whey
d) Herbs: Hyssop, eucalyptus, peppermint, thyme, fennel, fenugreek, garlic, elcampane
e) Remove animals to draft free well bedded outside environment !
f) Provide laxative, cleansing diet with bran, beet pulp, molasses mash; grass/hay

9) External Parasites
6 drops of essential oils of eucalyptus, citrus, thyme, melaleuca to 1/2 pint of vinegar, 1/4 pint turpentine, 1/4 pint linseed oil. Apply by rubbing & spraying.

10) Internal Parasites
Intensive rotational grazing; free choice minerals; force feed 4-8 oz. Diatomaceous Earth/head/day @three (3) weeks on, three (3) weeks off. Non-swelling montmorillionite @ 4-8 oz/head/day.
Herbs: garlic, clove, wormwood, wormseed, black walnut hulls. (Give at waxing of the moon).

Jerry Brunetti is a livestock consultant, feed formulator, and Director of Agri-Dynamics, selling herbal formulations, vitamins and minerals for livestock operations. He is often a speaker at the annual ACRES-USA conferences, and leads workshops on soil fertility, animal health and nutrition and medicinal herbs


www.organicmilk.org

Copyright 2002 - 2006
Northeast Organic Dairy Producers Alliance
30 Keets Rd, Deerfield MA 01342

info@organicmilk.org

Site designed and maintained by 3W Promotions

Thanks to the John Merck Fund for
supporting our organic dairy farmers with this web site.